Understanding Wrongful Pregnancy Claims: A Brief Legal Overview

The concept of wrongful pregnancy claims is both legally intricate and varies considerably across different states in the U.S. These claims are typically brought by parents against medical providers under the allegation of negligence leading to an unintended pregnancy. This blog post aims to elucidate the nature of these claims, their legal variability, and the importance of specialized legal advice.

What are Wrongful Pregnancy Claims?

A wrongful pregnancy claim is initiated by the parents of a healthy but unexpected, unplanned, or unwanted child. This lawsuit is directed against a medical provider for negligence that resulted in conception or pregnancy.

These claims often stem from negligently performed sterilization procedures. However, they can also arise from failures in diagnosing a pregnancy, performing an abortion, inserting or removing birth control devices, dispensing contraception prescriptions, or from contraceptive failures.

State-by-State Variations

The recognition of wrongful pregnancy claims varies significantly across the United States, and recent changes in abortion laws have added further complexity. 

As of now, 37 states recognize wrongful pregnancy as a valid legal claim, allowing parents to seek damages for the birth of an unplanned but healthy child due to medical negligence. However, several states have explicitly rejected such claims through legislation or court rulings, including Idaho, Utah, South Dakota, Minnesota, Oklahoma, Arkansas, Missouri, Kentucky, Michigan, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, and Georgia.

Even among states that recognize wrongful pregnancy, the scope of recoverable damages differs. In some states, parents may recover only the costs associated with the pregnancy and delivery. Others—like California, New Jersey, and Washington—allow for additional compensation, such as emotional distress or lost income, though limitations may apply. 

Importantly, abortion bans enacted after the Supreme Court’s decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization may indirectly impact related tort claims. In some states, the lack of a legal right to abortion complicates or weakens wrongful pregnancy and related claims by undermining key elements like causation and injury. As courts begin to reexamine prior decisions that relied on now-overturned precedents like Roe v. Wade, outcomes may shift further—particularly in politically conservative states.

Knowing Your Rights

Wrongful pregnancy claims involve complex legal and emotional issues that require clear evidence of medical negligence—such as a failed sterilization procedure or improper contraceptive advice—directly leading to an unplanned pregnancy. Calculating damages can also be challenging, as they may include medical expenses, lost wages, and, in some states, child-rearing costs or emotional distress. 

Whether you want to know more about wrongful pregnancy lawsuits or just want a better understanding of how our legal system works, LegalFix is your go-to source for legal information. 

LegalFix offers legal plans as an employee benefit for SMBs and as a membership benefit for credit unions. Ask your employer, employee benefits broker, insurance broker, credit union, or other membership group for preferred pricing today. 

LegalFix also provides helpful articles and state-specific explanations of nearly 1,600 legal topics—and allows you to browse state and federal statutes to better understand the laws that affect you.