A Brief Overview of the U.S. Military Justice System


LegalFix
Posted: November 12, 2024
military justice system

The United States military is an esteemed institution that operates under a distinct set of laws, codes, and procedures, particularly when it comes to legal matters. While you might be familiar with civilian courts, the military justice system is an entirely separate realm that deserves its own spotlight.

Uniform Code of Military Justice & Manual for Courts-Martial 

At the heart of the military justice system is the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ). This code, enacted by Congress, provides both substantive and procedural laws for military members, whether they're in training or on active duty. The President further refines these laws, prescribing rules and potential punishments in the Manual for Courts-Martial (MCM).

Investigation & Legal Proceedings

When a service member is suspected of committing a serious offense, specialized investigative agencies, like the Army's Criminal Investigation Command (CID), step in. Less severe cases might be handled by military police, and minor offenses could see commanders conduct preliminary inquiries.

One key difference between civilian and military systems lies in the discretion commanders have. They can decide the gravity of the offense and choose an appropriate action. This can range from taking no action to initiating administrative actions or even court-martial proceedings.

Levels of Court-Martial

There are three tiers of court-martial in the military justice system:

  • Summary Court-Martial: This handles minor offenses and only concerns enlisted soldiers. Here, the process is overseen by a single officer, without the accused's right to counsel, though they may hire an attorney.

  • Special Court-Martial: Acting as an intermediate level, it involves either a military judge or at least three members plus a judge. Here, there's both a prosecutor and a defense counsel. The accused also has the option to be represented by a civilian counsel.

  • General Court-Martial: This is the apex of military trial courts, handling the most severe crimes. Before proceeding, an Article 32 investigation is obligatory. The court may either consist of a military judge and a minimum of five members or solely a military judge.

Much like civilian trials, court-martial trials adhere to a pattern of evidence. However, it's notable that the military follows the Federal Rules of Evidence. An accused is entitled to a review post-conviction, and appeals can go as far as the United States Supreme Court, though such instances are exceedingly rare.Like with other courts, proceedings are often a matter of public record, unless there is a specific reason for them to be sealed. For example, court-martial summaries, docket information, filings, and records for the U.S. Army are available through the US Army Court-Martial Public Record System

The Value of Legal Expertise 

Understanding the nuances of the military justice system underscores the importance of having legal representation well-versed in military law. For those in the armed forces or their families, this specialized knowledge is paramount.

Having affordable and reliable access to an attorney with expertise in military law ensures that service members are appropriately represented and their rights are safeguarded. Every nuance, from the unique procedures to the distinct terminologies, makes military law a unique field. 

While the military justice system may seem intricate, it's a testament to the dedication the U.S. holds to ensuring fairness and justice for its service members. It reinforces the truth that even those who serve need robust legal support, especially from professionals familiar with the intricacies of military law.

Whether you want to know more about the U.S. military justice system or just want a better understanding of how our legal system works, LegalFix is your go-to source for legal information. LegalFix offers prepaid legal services as an employee benefit for SMBs and as a membership benefit for credit unions. Ask your employer, employee benefits broker, insurance broker, credit union, or other membership group for preferred pricing today. 

You can also find helpful articles and state-specific explanations of nearly 1,600 legal topics—or browse state and federal statutes to better understand the laws that affect you.


Legal Services for Less than 99¢ a Day

As a LegalFix member, you'll get expert legal services from a local law firm that treats you like an important client. Don't wait—be prepared for life's inevitable legal challenges starting today. And ask your employer, credit union, or membership group about preferred pricing opportunities.